It's No Surprise - Food Is Better Than Vitamin/Mineral Supplements!

April 11, 2019

In a large study which surveyed US adults about their supplement intake, then followed them for around 6 years, researchers found that most dietary supplements don't appear to help avoid death.

In a large study which surveyed US adults about their supplement intake, then followed them for around 6 years, researchers found that most dietary supplements don't appear to help avoid death. Not only that, but where there was a benefit to health during life, it was only where the nutrient came from food, not supplements.

The study was published in the Annals of Internal Medicine .

Researchers studied 31,000 U.S. adults who answered survey questions about their supplement intake in the past 30 days and about their diet over the past 24 hours. During a median 6 years' follow-up, 12% died.

They did find that those taking supplements had a reduced chance of death from any cause, but that seemed more due to them having healthier lifestyles, having had higher education and incomes. There was only a benefit from a supplement called Lycopene, which is in high levels in tomatoes.  

Adequate intake of vitamin K and magnesium was tied to lower mortality risk, but this was restricted to intake from food (vegetables, nuts and seeds are good sources). Excess calcium intake was actually associated with a 62% higher chance of dying from cancer, but they believed this was due to people taking high-dose supplements. (this is not an uncommon finding - calcium from food is vital, but supplemental calcium in high doses should only be taken under medical advice)

The researchers concluded: "The evidence suggests that adequate nutrient intake from foods was associated with reduced mortality and excess intake from supplements could be harmful."

More blog posts from Ngaire

Boost Gut Health and Fight Frailty

September 26, 2021

Eating to keep your gut bacteria happy might also help you avoid devastating frailty later in life.

Read this post

Brains like REAL food and drink!

September 3, 2021

Artificial sweeteners could be potentially harmful to our all-important gut microbiome according to recent research.

Read this post

Oatmeal (porridge) that packs a protein punch

May 25, 2021

In my occasional cooking segments, here is an idea for a higher protein breakfast of porridge/oatmeal.

Read this post